TWiV 266: A pathogenic vicious cycle

January 5, 2014

Hosts: Vincent Racaniello, Alan Dove, and Kathy Spindler

Vincent, Alan, and Kathy discuss finding viruses in outer space, varying results obtained from personal genetic testing, and depletion of CD4 cells during HIV infection by pyroptosis.

Click arrow to play
Download TWiV 266 (70 MB .mp3, 97 min)
Subscribe (free): iTunesRSSemail

Links for this episode

Weekly Science Picks

Kathy – 17 mundane things, mind blowing views
Alan – Snowovel
Vincent – Public’s views on human evolution

Listener Pick of the Week

Emily – Dengue pillow 

Send your virology questions and comments (email or mp3 file) to

dengue knit

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

10 comments on “TWiV 266: A pathogenic vicious cycle

  1. Karol Jan 6, 2014

    Guys don’t you think that it is little bit weird that a guy who lives 30 years with HIV and is still alive, and he is the example how HIV kills CD4 in vivo?

    • Most of the data in the paper were done with normal lymphoid tissue explants. The experiments with the elite controller were confirmatory but did not establish the concept. I don’t think it’s weird at all – most people with AIDS would be treated and hence not suitable for this study.

      • Karol Jan 6, 2014

        Why would you use an example that contradicts your data.The elite controllers are small percentage among people who have HIV .
        They present this process of cell death as fast end efficient and then they show a guy who presumably dealt with that for 30 years? For me it means that you can have low number of CD4 and live normally without taking any drugs.

        • I do understand your concern. I’m going to bring this up on TWiV this Friday and see what the others think. It is strange to demonstrate pyroptosis in an individual who is free from disease!

          • Scientist Jan 9, 2014

            He is not free from disease! He has very low CD4 T-cell count (156 cells / ul) and high viral load (85,756 copies/ml at the time of lymph node resection. He decided not to take ART since he was diagnosed.

          • Interesting. Many elite controllers have normal CD4 T cell counts. The viral load would make him *not* an elite controller.

  2. Juan Raygoza Jan 11, 2014

    One cannot hunt for viruses anywhere if we haven’t yet found a host for the viruses to infect in the first place.

    • Artem Baydaluk Jan 11, 2014

      If one found a virus somewhere it would be an evidence that more complex form of life must exist there.(or possibly it could be a contaminant from Earth)

      • Juan Raygoza Jan 11, 2014

        Also, it would have to be a complete virus, otherwise just because you found a protein or other biomolecule it may not be possible to assign it to a virus or bacteria. Also, in the case that we did find something that resembles something here on earth we could not be sure of it’s function because it is under different conditions. For example if we found there something that looks like a capsid here on earth, on other planet it may be used as a receptor, since that planet’s conditions may allow it to behave that way.

        • Artem Baydaluk Jan 11, 2014

          Our view is restricted (no doubts), but we can presume that some principles of life on Earth can be similar to those on the planets with similar permissible conditions, so finding a partial viral genome sequence may give us possibility to say that life exists there and resembles life on earth. Of course, we should search only on the certain planets. I think it is quite hard or impossible to predict principles of life, others than on Earth, to seek for on the other planets, therefore hunting for viruses in space is much easier.